New $2,000 medicare deductible?

Robbing tomorrow's seniors to pay for today's tax cuts

October 14, 2010

Republican senate hopeful Rand Paul, speaking on FOX News Sunday, suggested that in the near future, seniors should pick up of the first $2,000 of medical expenses that are currently paid for by Medicare. It was no off-the-cuff remark – Paul’s opponent has released a video showing him advancing this idea before a number of groups.

While some may applaud Paul’s proposal as fiscal responsibility, we condemn it as the exact opposite: more of the same “live-in-the-moment” nonsense that brought the Baby Boom generation dual-income households, permanent credit card debt and home equity loans that have families living so far beyond their means that they pine away for those nostalgic paycheck-to-paycheck days.

Because if Paul’s plan is to use this plan to offset the cost of extending the Bush tax cuts – including those for the super wealthy – it’s simply more of the snake oil we’ve so often been sold.

Why even talk  about cutting Medicare benefits? Recently passed health care reforms actually extended the viability of the current Medicare program through 2029, and reduce overall costs for the next 75 years, according to the bi-partisan Medicare Trustees’ annual report. There is no immediate crisis to fix, although certainly tweaks will need to continue to keep the program solvent.

Will Paul’s plan make Medicare more solvent? No, it would put cash in people’s pockets today, shifting the burden down the road to tomorrow’s seniors. Well guess what fellow Boomers, those future seniors are you.

What is it with us Baby Boomers? Are we missing the “delay of gratification” gene? Did growing up on the hyper-stimulation of Sesame Street and MTV destroy our attention spans? What else could be the cause of our repeated attempts to rob from our future selves?

People mistakenly believe that Medicare is a social covenant between the government and seniors, but it’s actually between the government and workers. That small amount deducted from each paycheck guarantees that you will have health care and dignity when you reach retirement age. If you think $2,000 is hard to come up with now, wait until you’re on Social Security (another target of the “live-for-today-not-for-tomorrow” crew).

Fellow Boomers, its time to pay the piper. We need to elect leaders who can see farther ahead than the next election. It was refreshing to see the Dems to start the long process of health care reform this last year, although we’ll be the ones paying the price is we punish them at the polls for acting like responsible adults.

We’ve fought two foreign wars for a decade, without any financial sacrifices from those of us sitting safely at home,. When else in history have we ever done such a thing? Do we want to go back to this same voodoo fiscal management that brought us to the brink of disaster two years ago?

No, we don’t. We need to draw a line in the sand on Medicare. No more dismantling our future for today’s short-term and fleeting needs.

To paraphrase Charleton Heston, you can have my Medicare benefits when you pry them “from my cold dead hands.” Because up until then, I’ll need them.


About Chuck Smith-Dewey

Chuck Smith-Dewey

Smith-Dewey, a former freelance graphic artist, founded in 1994 as the result of personal experience with the difficulty that self-employed with pre-existing conditions have with finding and keeping affordable health insurance. Writing under the pseudonym "Uncle Hyggly" he has written and illustrated several regional…

All authors

Visit the authors page and find out who is behind all of the great content at™.

Latest Obamacare news & opinion

Obamacare open enrollment window

Fixing Obamacare’s broken window

Spreading out open enrollment would allow carriers and exchanges to maintain level…


The dental crisis that’s driving patients away

When increasing numbers of Americans cross the Mexican border to see a dentist ... you…


Health Wonk Review for April 10, 2014

Billy Wynne put together a great edition of Health Wonk Review over at Healthcare…

exchanges too big to succeed

Exchanges: too big to succeed?

This is the time for brainstorming, but how much are we willing to change? Could we…

Republican policy fail ACA

Will there be an ‘exodus’ to the exchanges?

Harold: Now, would you be happy or sad if there was this exodus to the exchanges? Jon: I…

uninformed Florida Obamacare

Can Obamacare work even better?

I think the average American voter is actually a charitable person, a big-hearted person.…


Reports of ACA demise: greatly exaggerated

For this edition of Curbside Consult, I Skyped with Dr. Jonathan Gruber, who is the Ford…

repeal Obamacare 2014

Obamacare: Irreplaceable, irrepealable

If you support the Affordable Care Act, know that your work is not yet done. And if you…

Health Wonk Review March Madness

Health Wonk Review for March 27, 2014

If you're one of those health policy diehards, definitely head over to the Health Affairs…

all posts

See all 365 blog posts.

Browse by date

Search within posts

Recent tweets @EyeOnInsurance

Fri Apr 18 06:19 2014 • reply • retweet • favorite

Fri Apr 18 06:18 2014 • reply • retweet • favorite

Fri Apr 18 06:15 2014 • reply • retweet • favorite