Bush: the gift that keeps on giving

W's appointee delivers lump of coal to working families, strikes down health reform's individual mandate

December 13, 2010

Health reform’s individual mandate provision – the requirement that all taxpayers purchase health insurance beginning in 2014 – has been struck down by a federal judge appointed by none other than President George W. Bush.

What is it with America’s continuing suffering inflicted by the former President? The deficit is about to go into hyperdrive with the ill-advised extension of Bush’s tax cuts for the rich. If Bush were a doctor, he should have been sued for malpractice for those original unprecendented tax cuts, the first such during wartime by any President.

“Don’t make any sacrifices now,” Bush told a post 9/11 America that was more than willing and able to make some sacrifices. “I’ll just put it on the credit card.”

Now U.S. District Judge Henry E. Hudson of Virginia is seeking to scuttle the health reform bill by ruling the government does not have the power to require individuals to purchase health insurance. Two other federal judges have  already upheld the constitutionality of the provision, so Hudson’s ruling is a departure – it puts him in the category of “activist judges” – a category Republicans routinely demagogue.

Requiring all people to purchase insurance – and requiring insurance companies to take all applicants – is the most logical way to make health insurance available to the greatest number of people at the lowest possible cost. It spreads the risk across the entire population, doing what insurance is intended to do.

If reform is derailed, hundreds of thousands of American families will continue to file bankruptcy each year because of medical bills. Even more Americans will delay treatment for serious medical conditions, or go without treatment altogether, because of a lack of health coverage.

The very rich and the very poor are most likely to continue to get service. Those who will suffer include the working middle class.

That’s why we consider Bush to be “the gift that keeps on giving.” We all remember the high judicial quality of his court picks. Those continue to feel like lumps of coal in working America’s stockings.


Tags: ACA, individual mandate, George Bush

About Chuck Smith-Dewey

Chuck Smith-Dewey

Smith-Dewey, a former freelance graphic artist, founded healthinsurance.org in 1994 as the result of personal experience with the difficulty that self-employed with pre-existing conditions have with finding and keeping affordable health insurance. Writing under the pseudonym "Uncle Hyggly" he has written and illustrated several regional…

All authors

Visit the authors page and find out who is behind all of the great content at healthinsurance.org™.

Latest Obamacare news & opinion

Health Wonk Review June 5 2014

Health Wonk Review for June 5, 2014

If you haven’t gotten your health policy fix, head over to Health Wonk Review –…


Looking beyond the botched ACA rollout

"People have given up on the repeal. There are very few people who want Congress to…

price responsive consumers

Figuring out how to put ‘skin in the game’

The studies indicate that people are very responsive to healthcare prices when they see…

Curbside Consult David Cutler

Can we ‘do the right thing’ profitably?

David Cutler was the author of a prescient and scathing 2010 analysis warning of the need…


Dem ad slays Obamacare-hating Republican

Of the nearly half a billion dollars that has been spent on political ads mentioning the…


Health Wonk Review for May 22, 2014

Summer's here (at least it is where I am) and with it comes a summer-y edition of Health…

Sabrina Corlette health reform

Obamacare: Just what the doctor ordered?

In Part 2 of my conversation with Sabrina Corlette, we talk about whether the Affordable…

Health Wonk Review May - 2014

Health Wonk Review for May 8, 2014

Just a reminder that if you're still looking for some compelling health policy reading…


‘Bros’ on board – and other promising signs

With 8 million Americans enrolled in Obamacare's exchanges – 28 percent of them young…

all posts

See all 379 blog posts.

Browse by date

Search within posts

Related terms

individual mandate

The Affordable Care Act requires nearly everyone to have health insurance that meets minimum standards. With some exceptions, people…

Recent tweets @EyeOnInsurance

Mon Aug 18 18:44 2014 • reply • retweet • favorite

Mon Aug 18 18:41 2014 • reply • retweet • favorite

Wed Aug 13 01:34 2014 • reply • retweet • favorite