Will ‘the bros’ buy health insurance in 2014?
Thanks to Obamacare's subsidies, millions of young Americans will likely think twice before refusing comprehensive health plans
August 31, 2013
- 96% of young adults (ages 21-27) will qualify for subsidies.
If your son (or boyfriend) is uninsured, send him this post
Some young men say they never go to the doctor. Why, they ask, should they buy into Obamacare?
What reform’s opponent don’t tell them is that under Obamacare, a 25-year-old waiter who lives in North Los Angeles and earns $17,200 a year will be able to purchase coverage from one of the state’s highest-rated insurers, Kaiser Permanente, for just $33 a month.
How can this be? One word: subsidies.
Next year, some 11 million young adults (18-34) who are now either uninsured or buying their own (usually bare-bones) insurance will be able to purchase excellent coverage in the exchanges. Since some 9 million of the 11 million earn less than $45,960 a year ($62,040 for a couple) they will be eligible for tax credits to help cover the premiums. Fully 96 percent of the youngest (21-27) will qualify for subsidies, says Linda Blumberg, a health policy analyst at the bipartisan Urban Institute.
Now that states have begun to announce the rates insurers will be charging in their marketplaces, we can move past speculation to discuss what young adults in particular cities actually will be paying, after applying those tax credits. Fear-mongers should blush.
Why Bronze plans will be popular
The example of a 25-year-old waiter in North L.A. buying coverage for just $33 a month assumes that he purchases Kaiser Permanente’s Bronze plan. As you may remember, the exchanges will offer four tiers of insurance: Platinum, Gold, Silver and Bronze. Plans in all four tiers will offer free preventive care and comprehensive coverage that includes the 10 essential benefits.
The only significant difference is that at one end of the spectrum, Platinum premiums will be higher, while co-pays and deductibles will be lower. At the other end, Bronze plans will cost less, but co-pays and deductibles will be higher.
In the exchanges, young adults under 30 also will be able to purchase high-deductible health plans (HDHPs). Often these catastrophic plans will be cheaper than Bronze plans. But subsidies cannot be used to buy them. Thus, HDHPs make sense only for relatively affluent young singles who earn over $45,960 and thus won’t qualify for tax credits. But most in this group already are covered – either by a parent’s plan or by their employer. In 2013, 91 percent were insured. They won’t be shopping in the exchanges.
The subsidies are designed to make a Silver plan affordable.
Here’s how they work: the government begins by looking at your income. As the table below reveals, the lawmakers who wrote the Affordable Care Act decided that a waiter who earns less than $17,235 (or 150 percent of the Federal Poverty Level) should not be expected to spend more than 4 percent of his income ($689) when purchasing health insurance in the exchanges.
|If you earn||Your expected contribution is|
|Up to 133% of FPL (up to $15,282)||2% of your income|
|133%-150% of FPL (up to $17,235)||3%-4% of your income|
|150%-200% of FPL (up to $22,980)||4%-6.3% of your income|
|200%-250% of FPL (up to $28,725)||6.3%-8.05% of your income|
|250%-300% of FPL (up to $34,470)||8.05%-9.5% of your income|
|300%-400% of FPL (up to $45,960)||9.5% of your income|
When calculating the tax credit, the IRS will make up the difference between the amount you are expected to contribute and the cost of the “benchmark” Silver plan where you live. (In every marketplace the “benchmark” is the second least expensive Silver plan. In North L.A., it is a Blue Shield PPO which carries a price tag of $2,376 a year.)
The 25-year old in our example is expected to kick in 4 percent of his income, or $688 ($17,200 x 0.04 = $688) toward the premium. Subtract $688 from the $2,376 premium, and he can count on a subsidy of $1,688. If he chooses the Silver plan, he will wind up paying only $57 a month. ($2,376 – $1,688 divided by 12 = $57)
But he doesn’t have to use the $1,688 to buy Silver coverage. He can apply his subsidy to any Platinum, Gold, Silver or Bronze plan sold in the exchange. The Bronze plans call for higher out-of pocket spending, but since he rarely visits a doctor, he’s not worried about co-pays and deductibles. The premium is most important. Moreover, in North LA, Kaiser Permanente offers a Bronze plan for just $174 a month $2,088 annually). After he uses his tax credit, it will cost him $33 a month, or $400 a year.
Bronze will be popular among 20-somethings, but it won’t be the best choice for all young adults. If he suffered from a chronic condition like asthma, and knew he might land in a hospital or an ER, he would be better off picking Silver coverage because Silver plans come with a silver lining: Anyone who earns less than $45,960 is eligible for a “cost-sharing subsidy” that will slash both his co-pays and his deductible. (This subsidy should not be confused with the separate “premium tax credit” that helps cover his premium.) For a full description of how the cost-sharing subsidy works see this “Frequently Asked Question”.
Bronze premiums around the U.S.
Nationwide, young adults using subsidies will be surprised by just how affordable insurance can be. In fact, some plans will cost less than the $695 penalty a Refusenik will owe in 2016.
- In Washington, D.C., a 27 year-old bike mechanic earning $22,900 will be able to buy a Kaiser Permanente Bronze plan for $99 a month. A 27 year-old dishwasher earning $15,280 would receive a subsidy of $1,512. With that, he could buy a Kaiser Permanente Bronze plan for $305 a year or about $25 a month. That’s less than the $325 penalty he would pay in 2015 if he ignored Obamacare.
- In New York City, a 34-year-old musician earning $28,000 a year could use his subsidy to purchase NY Fidelis’ Bronze plan for $1,304 a year, or $108 a month. (A 20-year-old and a 60-year-old earning $28,000 would pay the same price: in New York State, insurers cannot charge older customers more.)
- In Rochester, New York, hospitals and doctors charge less than in NYC. A freelance writer who brings in $28,000 will be able to buy a Freelancers plan for $812, or $67 a month.
- In Hartford, Connecticut, a 21-year-old who earns $15,200 working part-time at Wal-Mart could purchase a benchmark ConnectiCare Silver plan for $304 annually. If he chose ConnectiCare’sBronze plan, he would pay nothing since his $2,660 subsidy would exceed the $2,364 annual premium.
- In Sacramento, California, a 25-year-old who brings in $28,700 working as a line cook would be able to purchase a Kaiser Permanente Bronze Plan for $1,624 a year or $135 a month.
- In Denver, Colorado, a 27-year old who earns $24,000 managing a bookstore would receive a subsidy of $170 a month that will let him purchase coverage from Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of Colorado for $444, or $37 monthly.
- In Portland, Oregon, a 34-year-old ski patroller earning $22,380 could use his subsidy to buy a Moda Health Bronze plan for $79 a month ($948 annually).
Note that in this last example, for $948 a year, our “bro” would receive free preventive care, comprehensive insurance that covers all essential benefits, and three physicians visits for $45 before his deductible kicks in. Plus, his mother and his girlfriend would stop nagging him about not having insurance.
Or he could pay a penalty that will climb to $695 in 2016 – and receive nothing in return.
What would you do?
Tags: cost-sharing subsidies, essential benefits, HDHP, health insurance exchange, health insurance marketplace, high deductible health plan, premium subsidies, subsidies, young invincibles, Maggie Mahar