If you aren't hearing critics complaining that Obamacare isn't good enough, you're probably hearing them saying it's TOO good.

Obamacare ‘Medicaid for the middle class?’

Conservatives' latest slap at Obamacare is a truly muddled message

July 31, 2013
  • Now that projections of ‘sticker shock’ aren’t sticking, critics have regrouped, alternately claiming Obamacare is too good … and not good enough.

Yet another catchy phrase, “Medicaid for the middle class,” is popping up in conservative propaganda. What are Obamacare’s opponents trying to say?

Those who have latched onto this catchphrase make two very different arguments. The arguments actually contradict each other, but they have one thing in common: Both are untrue.

Obamacare isn’t good enough?

#1 ) Obamacare isn’t good enough because the coverage families will receive in the exchanges will limit them to a tiny network of providers.

Originally, conservatives claimed that Obamacare would be too expensive. Americans who tried to buy insurance in the exchanges would experience “Sticker Shock!” Now that states have begun to announce premiums, it’s becoming apparent that this isn’t true.

So conservatives have regrouped. In an about-face, they are acknowledging that some plans offered in the exchanges may be affordable, but this, they say, is because insurers are limiting their networks to providers who will accept lower fees.

Reform’s critics insinuate that “narrow networks” will exclude top-notch doctors and hospitals. The Citizens’ Council on Health Freedom (CCHF) calls exchange coverage “second-tier Medicaid for the middle class.”

Nevertheless, CHCF says, “Many people are expected to choose narrow-network plans that offer a limited choice of doctors, clinics and hospitals … because the cost will be less.”

Note that, while grousing about “limited choice,” CHCF predicts that patients will “choose” narrow networks.

When you’re fibbing, it’s easy to begin contradicting yourself. The truth is that people who have not been able to afford insurance in the past are far more interested in price than they are in the size of the network.

Moreover, many Baby Boomers already have embraced HMOs: they charge less when a patient stays “in network,” and the best focus on keeping patients healthy.

In fact, when Consumer Reports published NCQA ratings of quality and customer satisfaction HMOs out-ranked other insurers.

‘Narrow’ doesn’t necessarily mean ‘not as good’

Everything turns on who is included, who is left out – and why.

In the exchanges, insurers will be competing on price. As a result, carriers are pushing back against providers that over-charge – including brand-name hospitals that demand far more for very simple procedures.

The push-back could help rein in health care inflation: “As narrow networks continue to exclude high-priced, academic hospitals … we expect they will consider re-pricing,” says Jenny Kerr, Market Analyst at HealthLeaders-InterStudy.

Both insurers and “employers are sending a message that they are no longer willing to pay for hospitals that charge higher rates for routine services to cover costs of their teaching and research missions,” Kerr adds.

For example, employers (in this case the city of Los Angeles)  as well as exchange insurers are rejecting LA’s pricey Cedars-Sinai Medical Center.

Cedars-Sinai boasts a reputation as “hospital to the stars.” Among the nation’s 50 top-grossing non-profit hospitals, it ranks third. But this does not necessarily mean that it provides superior care. In 2012 when the Joint Commission released its list of the Top Performers on Key Quality Measures, Cedars-Sinai did not make the cut.

By contrast, Kaiser Permanente’s hospitals stand out on the Joint Commission’s list. Little wonder that the exchanges are embracing Kaiser. Not only does Consumer Reports gives Kaiser stellar marks for quality,  the premiums Kaiser will be charging California’s 40-year-olds for a Silver Plan are among the lowest in the state.

#2) Obamacare is too good (too generous)

As 11th-hour conservative hysteria mounts, Rush Limbaugh, et. al. are now claiming that under Obamacare, multi-millionaire early retirees will be able to sign up for Medicaid. This, they argue, is another example of how the ACA offers “Medicaid for the Middle-Class.”

Under the Affordable Care Act, it turns out that regulators don’t count Social Security income when deciding who qualifies for Medicaid. Thus reform’s critics fantasize that a 62-year-old couple with $2 million in assets, each receiving $23,500 in Social Security income (the maximum for high earners), and less than $17,000 in other taxable income, will wind up on Medicaid’s rolls.

First, find me a couple with $2 million in savings, each of whom have been high earners for 40 years, and now have just $17,000 in taxable income other than Social Security.

More to the point, find me a pair of affluent 62-year-olds who would be willing to limit their circle of doctors to the one-third who will open their doors to new Medicaid patient.

Finding a specialist could be particularly difficult. If our 62-year-old millionaires settled for Medicaid, they could easily find themselves sitting in the basement of a hospital, surrounded by the poorest of the poor, waiting to see a resident. (In many hospitals, only residents staff the clinics that take Medicaid patients.)

Still, Medicare actuary Richard Foster (never a fan of Obamacare) told AP that he “lays awake at night worrying that these people will wind up on Medicaid,” ripping off taxpayers.

Yet the actuary’s own office acknowledges that its $64,000 example would represent an “unusual case.”

To say the least.

Tags: ACA, Affordable Care Act, Citizens Council on Health Freedom, Consumer Reports, HMO, Kaiser Permanente, Medicaid, Obamacare, Social Security, Maggie Mahar, Rush Limbaugh

About Maggie Mahar

Maggie Mahar

Maggie Mahar is an author and financial journalist who has written extensively about the American health care system. Her book, Money-Driven Medicine: The Real Reason Health Care Costs So Much, was the inspiration for the documentary, Money Driven Medicine (which Mahar also co-wrote). She is…

All authors

Visit the authors page and find out who is behind all of the great content at healthinsurance.org™.

Latest Obamacare news & opinion

Moral Mondays

Pre-Occupied with Medicaid expansion

Moral Mondays focuses on concrete, politically actionable grievances. Punitive voter ID…

Obamacare open enrollment window

Fixing Obamacare’s broken window

Spreading out open enrollment would allow carriers and exchanges to maintain level…


The dental crisis that’s driving patients away

When increasing numbers of Americans cross the Mexican border to see a dentist ... you…


Health Wonk Review for April 10, 2014

Billy Wynne put together a great edition of Health Wonk Review over at Healthcare…

exchanges too big to succeed

Exchanges: too big to succeed?

This is the time for brainstorming, but how much are we willing to change? Could we…

Republican policy fail ACA

Will there be an ‘exodus’ to the exchanges?

Harold: Now, would you be happy or sad if there was this exodus to the exchanges? Jon: I…

uninformed Florida Obamacare

Can Obamacare work even better?

I think the average American voter is actually a charitable person, a big-hearted person.…


Reports of ACA demise: greatly exaggerated

For this edition of Curbside Consult, I Skyped with Dr. Jonathan Gruber, who is the Ford…

repeal Obamacare 2014

Obamacare: Irreplaceable, irrepealable

If you support the Affordable Care Act, know that your work is not yet done. And if you…

all posts

See all 366 blog posts.

Browse by date

Search within posts

Related terms

Affordable Care Act (ACA)

The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA) – also known as the Affordable Care Act or ACA, and generally…


Medicaid is a health insurance program for low-income individuals and those with disabilities. Elderly low-income people are eligible…

Recent tweets @EyeOnInsurance

Wed Apr 23 21:54 2014 • reply • retweet • favorite

Wed Apr 23 15:20 2014 • reply • retweet • favorite

Wed Apr 23 14:52 2014 • reply • retweet • favorite