- Who might consider short-term coverage?
- Short-term plans offer help for millions who can’t afford ACA coverage.
- Short-term plans do not cover ACA’s essential health benefits.
- Duration of short-term plans vary by state due to state regulations.
- Consumers can buy short-term plans online.
- Enrollment in short-term plans is available year-round.
- Premiums vary considerably, depending on factors such as your age.
- Short-term plans provide coverage for a variety of medically necessary care.
- There are 11 states where short-term plans aren’t available for purchase.
- Plans typically don’t cover pre-existing medical conditions.
What is short-term health insurance and why do I need it?
Designed for healthy individuals and families, short-term health insurance policies provide an affordable safety net for consumers who – due to changing circumstances – may find themselves temporarily without comprehensive health insurance or unable to afford comprehensive coverage.
These plans are attractive to people who don’t qualify for premium subsidies in the health insurance marketplace, or who missed open enrollment and are otherwise facing a gap in coverage. This includes people who are between jobs, retiring prior to Medicare eligibility, or those who have already enrolled in other insurance coverage (an employer’s plan or an ACA-compliant individual market plan, for example) and are waiting for it to take effect.
A short-term health plan can also be used to bridge a gap in coverage if you’re newly employed and have a waiting period of up to three months before you gain eligibility for your employer’s health benefits plan.
Why would I buy a short-term plan – and not an ACA-compliant plan?
There are currently about 2.2 million people caught in the coverage gap in 12 states that have refused to expand Medicaid. Their household incomes are under the federal poverty level, so paying full price for health insurance is probably a non-starter.
Others are caught by the family glitch, and although their coverage is technically considered “affordable,” that may not actually be the case.
The American Rescue Plan did eliminate the subsidy cliff for 2021 and 2022, meaning that households with income over 400% of the poverty level can qualify for a premium subsidy if the cost of the benchmark plan would otherwise be more than 8.5% of the household’s income.
But the coverage gap and the family glitch continue to be problems. And subsidies are also not available to undocumented immigrants, who aren’t allowed to purchase coverage through the exchange even if they’re willing to pay full price.
If you’re among these consumers who don’t have access to affordable ACA-compliant coverage, it’s worth at least weighing the pros and cons of short-term coverage.
How is short-term health insurance different from ACA-compliant coverage?
Under federal rules, short-term plans are not required to cover the ACA’s essential health benefits. So in most states where short-term health plans are available, the available plans tend to have more benefit limitations than ACA-compliant plans, and gaps in their coverage for at least some of the essential health benefit categories.
The most commonly excluded categories of coverage are maternity care, mental health care, preventive care, and prescription drugs, although short-term plans can be designed to include or exclude whatever services they choose, unless states require certain mandated benefits to be covered. (Click on your state on the map above to see plan availability and information about how short-term health insurance is regulated in each state).
Most short-term plans will provide at least some coverage for medically necessary inpatient and outpatient medical care, including emergency services. But there are generally blanket exclusions for any pre-existing condition that the enrollee may have, and the plans will often impose limits on the amount the plan will pay for certain services.
How long will a short-term health plan cover me?
Depending on where you live and the insurance company you select, it’s possible to get a short-term plan that can last for a total duration of up to three years, including renewals.
The insurer may offer the option to lock in guaranteed renewability, without additional medical underwriting, when the policy is purchased, meaning that the applicant would only have to apply once and could be covered for up to three years. (Note that in most states, short-term health insurers are not required to offer renewability. Check the plan details carefully before purchasing coverage, to make sure you understand what you’re buying.)
About half the states have stricter rules, however, and do not allow plans to remain in effect for a full three years. And even in states where longer short-term plans are allowed, some insurers choose to only offer shorter terms and/or non-renewable plans.
Who is eligible to purchase short-term health insurance?
As long as you can pass the cursory medical underwriting involved in most short-term health plan applications (a very short series of yes/no questions about major medical events), you can purchase a short-term plan. But be aware that the plan will likely exclude any pre-existing medical condition, even if it’s not mentioned in the list of health questions asked on the application.
How do consumers buy short-term health insurance coverage?
Short-term health insurance is typically purchased online, although paper applications and in-person enrollments are available in some cases. Short-term health insurance can be obtained via a website that offers numerous plan options, or directly from an insurance company that sells short-term plans.
Short-term health plans are offered by several national companies that sell plans in numerous states, as well as regional companies that have more localized service areas, so short-term plan availability varies considerably depending on where you live.
Short-term health insurance plans are available in most states, but there are 11 states where no short-term plans are available, due to either outright bans or state laws that are unattractive to the insurers that offer short-term health plans.
When can I enroll in a short-term health plan?
Enrollment is available year-round, albeit with medical underwriting. So you can enroll or change plans anytime you like, without having to wait for an open enrollment period.
How long will it take me to get short-term insurance?
With short-term policies, healthy applicants can secure immediate individual and family coverage, with plans that can kick in as early as the next day. If you already know the number of days you will need to be covered, your insurer may allow you to make a single payment for the whole coverage period.
The application process for short-term health insurance is typically quite simple, with just a handful of yes/no questions about medical history. As long as your answer to all of the questions is “no,” you’ll generally be accepted for coverage with an effective date as soon as the following day.
(It’s important to understand that short-term healthcare plans generally rely on post-claims underwriting, which means they’ll go back and take a closer look at your medical history if and when you experience an injury or illness that results in a medical claim, to ensure that the condition was not pre-existing.)
How much does short-term health insurance cost?
The monthly premiums for short-term health insurance vary considerably depending on where you live, your age, and the insurance company that’s offering the coverage. Depending on the circumstances, they can start at well under $100/month.
Although premium subsidies are not available for short-term policies, the plans do tend to be considerably less expensive than ACA-compliant major medical plans if you’re not eligible for a premium subsidy.
But if you are eligible for a premium subsidy, you may find that the after-subsidy cost for an ACA-compliant plan is even less than the cost of a short-term plan — possibly even free. This is especially true for 2021 and 2022, thanks to the American Rescue Plan‘s premium subsidy enhancements.
How do short-term health insurance premiums compare to ACA plan premiums?
A lower monthly premium is the primary draw for short-term plans. Consider a single 45-year-old, living in southwestern Wyoming and earning an income of $12,000/year (there’s an ACA-specific calculation for household income). That’s under the poverty level, and Wyoming has not accepted federal funding to expand Medicaid. That means this person is ineligible for Medicaid, and they’re also ineligible for premium subsidies in the exchange/marketplace (ie, they’re in the coverage gap).
The least expensive ACA-compliant plan available to this person will cost $593/month. That’s obviously unrealistic with an income of only a thousand dollars a month.
But if we look at short-term plans, there are policies available with premiums starting at a little over $100/month. That’s still a stretch for someone earning $12,000/year, but it’s much more feasible than $593/month. The deductible will be in the range of $10,000 (versus $8,550 for the least-expensive ACA-compliant plan), and the out-of-pocket maximum will be $20,000 (versus $8,550 for the ACA-compliant plan).
Some of the available short-term plans have a maximum duration of six months, while others allow up to 364 days of coverage. There are several plan designs available, and although none of them are as comprehensive as ACA-compliant plans, the trade-off is that they have much lower premiums.
(It should be noted that if this person had an income of $13,000, instead of $12,000, they would be eligible for a premium subsidy of more than $900 per month, which would allow them to choose from several premium-free ACA-compliant plans in the Wyoming exchange. None of the available plans would cost more than $8/month, even for the most comprehensive options.)
What does short-term health insurance cover?
Short-term health insurance policies are designed to cover at least some of the cost of unexpected medical events that are not linked to a pre-existing condition. The plans will generally provide coverage for inpatient and emergency care, surgeries, and various outpatient services, lab work, and imaging.
Some short-term plans include inpatient prescription drugs, although it’s much less common for short-term plans to cover prescriptions that you’d pick up at the pharmacy.
|States where you can’t buy short-term health plans|
Can I buy short-term insurance in my state?
Though short-term plans are available in most states, there are 11 states where short-term plans aren’t available at all. In New York, New Jersey, Maine, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, Vermont, California, Colorado, Hawaii, Connecticut, and New Mexico, there are no short-term plans for sale in 2021.
In some cases, this is because state regulations ban them outright, while in other cases it’s because state regulations are strict enough that insurers have opted not to sell short-term plans. (In Washington, short-term plans with January effective dates cannot be purchased between November 1 and December 15, but are otherwise available.)
Short-term plans are available in the remaining states, but regulations and availability vary considerably from state to state. (Click on the map above to see how short-term plans are regulated within the state.)
Will short-term plans cover my doctors?
Short-term health insurance plans cover a range of physician services, surgery, outpatient and inpatient care. In addition, policyholders can sometimes choose their own doctor and hospital without restrictions, though there may be financial incentives for using in-network providers.
If the short-term plan has a provider network, the provider’s total payment will be adjusted to match the insurer’s approved reimbursement rate, with the cost split between the health plan and the policyholder according to the terms of the plan. But if the health plan does not have a provider network — often touted as a benefit that provides freedom to see any doctor — enrollees should be aware of how balance billing works. This is described in more detail below.
Does short-term health insurance cover pre-existing conditions?
Even if you’re eligible for coverage based on the short list of questions asked on the application, you will generally not have coverage for any pre-existing medical conditions while you’re enrolled in the plan. Short-term plans exist solely to provide coverage for medical conditions that have not yet arisen – and will not be any help at all in terms of medical conditions you already have.
Be sure to check the list of exclusions on any policy. Short-term plans also tend to use post-claims underwriting, which means they will generally take your word for your health status when you enroll, but can then go back through your medical history if and when you have a claim, making sure that you were truthful on your application and verifying any pre-existing conditions.
What are other possible drawbacks of short-term health plans?
What are some of the factors that might make consumers reluctant to buy short-term coverage?
You may be subject to balance billing
Some short-term plans tout the fact that you can see any doctor or go to any hospital you want. While that might sound good, it’s also a red flag for potential balance billing. If the plan doesn’t have a provider network, that means the doctors and hospitals that members end up using have not agreed to accept the insurer’s reimbursement rates as payment in full.
In that case, whatever amount the insurer pays them (a “reasonable and customary” amount, a percentage of Medicare rates, etc.) is likely to be less than what they billed. And since they do not have a contract with the short-term insurer, they are free to send a bill to the patient for whatever amount the insurance plan doesn’t pay.
So even if the plan has a maximum out-of-pocket limit, enrollees should keep in mind that balance billing could potentially result in much higher out-of-pocket costs if the plan doesn’t limit care to a specific network of providers.
You could still end up facing a gap in coverage.
When your short-term plan ends, you will not be eligible to purchase a regular plan in the individual market if it’s outside of open enrollment. Loss of minimum essential coverage is a qualifying event that triggers a special enrollment period, but a short-term plan is not considered minimum essential coverage.
But if you’re buying short-term coverage to get you through to the end of the year, you’ll be able to purchase an ACA-compliant plan during open enrollment that will take effect the first of the coming year. And if you’re going to be starting a new job that offers health insurance, you’ll be able to enroll in your new employer’s plan as soon as you’re eligible.
(It’s worth noting that the termination of a short-term plan does trigger a special enrollment period for group health coverage. (See page 51 of the 2018 rule for short-term plans). So if you have access to your employer’s plan but hadn’t enrolled — and had enrolled in a short-term plan instead — the termination of your short-term plan would allow you a special enrollment period during which you could enroll in your employer’s plan.)
That last point is important to keep in mind. If you purchase a 364-day plan in July and then suffer a serious illness or injury the following April, you could find yourself in a predicament if the plan you purchased was not guaranteed renewable. (Under the federal rules, insurers have the option to offer guaranteed renewability, but are not required to do so; some states do require renewability, but they’re the exception).
Depending on your medical situation, you may not be able to purchase another short-term plan when yours expires in June. And you wouldn’t be eligible for a special enrollment period to buy an ACA-compliant plan, since the termination of a short-term plan is not a qualifying event. More than likely, you’d have to wait for open enrollment in order to sign up for a new plan, which would take effect January 1.
So you could find yourself uninsured for several months (in this case, July through December), and it might be at a time when you have ongoing medical needs related to the illness or injury that made you uninsurable for a second short-term plan. This is complicated, and certainly requires more than a passing glance when you’re considering what coverage option to purchase.
Louise Norris is an individual health insurance broker who has been writing about health insurance and health reform since 2006. She has written dozens of opinions and educational pieces about the Affordable Care Act for healthinsurance.org. Her state health exchange updates are regularly cited by media who cover health reform and by other health insurance experts.