Find a plan.

adverse selection

What is adverse selection?

Adverse selection refers to a situation in which the buyers and sellers of an insurance product do not have the same information available. A common example with health insurance occurs when a person waits until he knows he is sick and in need of health care before applying for a health insurance policy.

This wasn’t an option in the medically underwritten model of individual health insurance (ie, pre-2014 in most states), because pre-existing conditions were a factor in determining eligibility and price.

But since 2014, individual health insurance policies have been guaranteed issue. There was concern that this would lead to adverse selection, with healthy people opting to not purchase health insurance and simply waiting until they needed coverage before enrolling. This would result in adverse selection, which could sharply increase premiums.

Indeed, premiums did increase significantly in the individual market in 2017 and 2018, due in large part to premiums being too low in the early years of ACA implementation, uncertainty about the future of the ACA and enforcement of the individual mandate under the Trump administration, and the Trump administration’s decision to cut off CSR funding. But premiums have stabilized significantly since then, with decreases or modest increases in most places from 2019 through 2021.

The ACA’s approach to avoiding adverse selection in a guaranteed-issue market is three-fold:

Even still, adverse selection remains a significant concern, especially in states where regulations allow healthy people to buy short-term health insurance with a total duration of up to three years, Farm Bureau health plans, or health care sharing ministry coverage.

Some insurers also worry that people are “gaming the system” and qualifying for special enrollment periods when they shouldn’t. There was no widespread evidence of SEP fraud, but eligibility verification was stepped up, starting in 2106.

Enrollment in off-exchange (ACA-compliant) individual/family health insurance has declined over the last several years (off-exchange enrollees have to pay full price for their coverage, as no subsidies are available outside the exchange; the sharp premium increases in 2017 and 2018 resulted in many off-exchange enrollees dropping their coverage and either obtaining coverage elsewhere or going uninsured). But on-exchange enrollment reached a record high in 2021, illustrating the power of premium subsidies in keeping adverse selection at bay.

Related articles

Peter Morley's own health issues spurred him to meet with members of Congress more than 275 times to advocate for the millions with pre-existing conditions
The debate over protection for people with pre-existing conditions has become a proxy war for what matters most on the healthcare front in West Virginia (and other poor red states).
Patrick Carr went an awfully long time without health insurance. For someone living with two chronic health conditions — asthma and high blood pressure — doing without health insurance for more than 12 years was downright dangerous. Carr says his health suffered as a result, but he didn’t have a choice.