2018 enrollment update
- Eight insurers offering plans for 2018.
- Effectuated enrollment for 2018 was 2.4% higher than 2017’s.
Massachusetts is a leader in public health and healthcare reform, enacting legislation in 2006 that resulted in the nation’s lowest uninsured rate – a designation the state continues to hold, with an uninsured rate of just 2.5 percent in 2016, according to US Census data.
Massachusetts’ reform strategies, such as an exchange where private insurers compete, a requirement that individuals have coverage or pay a penalty, and subsidies to help those who can’t afford coverage, served as the model Affordable Care Act. The state’s individual mandate will continue to be in effect in 2019 and beyond, after the ACA’s individual mandate penalty is repealed.
Massachusetts runs a state-based health insurance exchange called Massachusetts Health Connector and has expanded Medicaid. Additionally, it provides additional state-based subsidies to exchange enrollees eligible for its ConnectorCare program. As of 2017, those with subsidized health insurance plans through the Massachusetts exchange no longer have to pay copays for outpatient substance abuse treatment or medications.
Three bills, which were introduced in 2017 and are under consideration in 2018 in the Massachusetts legislature, address the possibility of a public option in Massachusetts (S.638), or a state-based Medicare for All option (S.619 and H.2987). The public option would be a new insurance option that would be available exclusively via the Massachusetts Health Connector, and would be sold alongside the other private health plans that offer coverage through the Connector. The Massachusetts Campaign for Single Payer Health Care has more information about the Medicare for All proposals.
Massachusetts health ratings
Massachusetts consistently performs among the top five states in several public health ratings. For 2015, it ranked third in America’s Health Rankings, but on the 2017 edition of the Rankings, Massachusetts was the top-ranked state.
With the nation’s lowest uninsured rate and highest number of primary care physicians per 100,000 people, the state has clear strengths when it comes to access to healthcare. According to this particular report, the state’s biggest public health challenge is a large disparity in health status – Massachusetts ranked 41st for that measure on the 2017 edition of the Rankings (up from 49th in the 2015 edition). And although Massachusetts was ranked number one in 2017, the state has experienced a 69 percent increase in the number of drug deaths since 2012.
The Commonwealth Fund ranked Massachusetts fourth among the states and the District of Columbia in its 2015 Scorecard on State Health System Performance, but the state dropped to 5th in the 2017 edition of the Scorecard. Again, The Bay State topped the charts with its low uninsured rate, which contributed to its #2 ranking for the Access category. Massachusetts placed lowest in the Avoidable Hospital Use & Costs category, for which it placed 39th (down from 31st in the 2015 edition of the Scorecard). See the Massachusetts 2017 scorecard for additional details on the state’s performance in several categories and key indicators.
Another source of public health information and comparisons is the 2016 edition of Trust for America’s Health; see Key Health Data About Massachusetts. You can also compare health ranking for Massachusetts counties through the data published by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation and the Population Health Institute at the University of Wisconsin.
2018 health insurance plans and rates
The Massachusetts exchange continues to include several carrier options, with eight insurers offering plans in 2018. Five of the eight offer ConnectorCare plans as well as regular qualified health plans, while the other three only offer regular QHPs.
Massachusetts’ 2018 exchange carriers and their average rate increases (before premium subsidies are applied) are as follows:
- Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Massachusetts: 5.2 percent increase
- Boston Medical Center HealthNet Plan: 28.8 percent increase
- Fallon Community Health Plan: 16.8 percent increase
- Harvard Pilgrim Health Care (HMO): 7 percent increase
- Health New England: 12.4 percent increase
- Neighborhood Health Plan: 23.4 percent increase
- Tufts HMO: 5 percent increase
- Tufts Insurance Company: 19.9 percent increase
For the five insurers that offer ConnectorCare plans that include cost-sharing reductions (CSR), the average rate increases are much higher than they would otherwise have been, due to the cost of CSR being added to premiums just before the start of open enrollment, when the Trump Administration eliminated federal funding for CSR (details about how this worked in Massachusetts are here).
Minuteman Health and CeltiCare/Ambetter both exited the ACA-compliant market in Massachusetts at the end of 2017, and are no longer offering plans.
Massachusetts enrollment in qualified health plans
Prior to Obamacare’s individual mandate taking effect in 2014, Massachusetts had the lowest uninsured rate in the nation, at 3.7 percent. By 2016, it had fallen to 2.5 percent – still the nation’s lowest.
About 31,700 Massachusetts residents enrolled in qualified health plans (QHPs) during 2014 open enrollment. But this number wasn’t really reflective of actual demand, due to problems with Health Connector.
Enrollment in QHPs would have been much higher if it were not for the technical problems with the Health Connector. About 160,000 new applicants with incomes above 133 percent of poverty level who should have been enrolled in QHPS were instead temporarily enrolled in Medicaid and about 112,200 people ended up staying on their Commonwealth Care plans through the end of 2014.
Exchange enrollment has improved substantially ever since. For the 2016 open enrollment period, technology issues seemed to be a thing of the past and Massachusetts Health Connector, Massachusetts’ state-based exchange, exceeded its goal of 190,000 QHP enrollments, including renewals. When 2016 enrollment ended on January 1, there were 196,554 exchange enrollees. As of June 2, effectuated enrollment stood at 223,778. The majority of those individuals (171,000) were enrolled in ConnectorCare, a Massachusetts program that provides state subsidies in addition to federal ACA subsidies to those with incomes up to 300 percent of the poverty level. ConnectorCare enrollment lasts year-round.
And by 2018, plan selections during open enrollment (which was a week shorter than prior open enrollment periods had been) reached 270,688. By February 1, 2018, effectuated enrollment stood at 252,786, which was about 2.4 percent higher than it had been in 2017.
Massachusetts and the Affordable Care Act
Democrats dominate Massachusetts politics at the federal and state level, and support for Obamacare is solid. When the Affordable Care Act was up for a vote in the U.S. Senate, John Kerry and Scott Brown represented Massachusetts. Sen. Kerry voted yes of the ACA, while Brown voted no. Brown was elected in a special election following the death of Edward (Ted) Kennedy, who championed health care issues throughout his political career.
Brown was defeated in his re-election bid in 2012 by Elizabeth Warren, who supports the ACA and introduced legislation in 2018 to stabilize and protect it. Ed Markey, who also supports the ACA, was selected in a special election after Kerry assumed the role of U.S. Secretary of State.
In the U.S. House of Representatives, nine of 10 representatives voted in favor of the ACA. Rep. Stephen Lynch voted against the ACA, in part because the final legislation did not include a public option. All 10 Representatives from Massachusetts continue to be Democrats.
At the state level, former Gov. Deval Patrick in 2012 signed two bills to bring Massachusetts’ existing exchange and policies into compliance with the federal health care reform law. In addition, Massachusetts adopted the ACA’s expansion of Medicaid.
Gov. Charlie Baker was sworn into office in 2015. Baker is a Republican, and has been critical of the ACA. But Baker was among a bipartisan group of governors who called on Congressional Republicans to reject the partisan efforts to repeal the ACA in 2017, and he was critical of the Trump Administration’s decision in 2017 to end federal funding for cost-sharing reductions (CSR), noting that ending the funding could result in a destabilized individual health insurance market (ultimately, insurers simply added the cost of CSR to silver plan premiums, resulting in larger premium subsidies — which are funded by the federal government — and protecting most consumers from bearing the brunt of the price increase).
Massachusetts’ Obamacare implementation
The rollout of the ACA in Massachusetts did not go smoothly, despite the fact that the law was modeled on the state’s previous healthcare reform initiatives. The state had to modify many of its existing programs to comply.
Technical upgrades were needed to make Massachusetts’ state-based exchange, Massachusetts Health Connector, ACA-compliant. The upgrades were not implemented correctly or on time, causing many enrollment delays and requiring manual workarounds. The problems with the Health Connector affected not only those who were seeking to enroll for the first time, but also those who had existing state-subsidized coverage.
Prior to the ACA, Massachusetts operated Commonwealth Care, for individuals with incomes below 300 percent of the federal poverty level (FPL), and Commonwealth Choice, for uninsured adults who made too much to qualify for Commonwealth Care. Depending on income levels, some people previously enrolled in Commonwealth Care were transitioned to Medicaid. The rest of the Commonwealth Care population and the Commonwealth Choice population become eligible for federal subsidies to purchase new health plans through Health Connector.
Given the problems with the Health Connector, Massachusetts was forced to keep many people enrolled in their Commonwealth Care plans and temporarily enroll new applicants in the Medicaid program. These temporary fixes expired at the end of the year, and about 400,000 people had to re-apply for coverage by Dec. 31, 2014.
After much analysis, Massachusetts decided to fix the Health Connector rather than transition to the federal marketplace. By October 2015, the total cost of rebuilding Health Connector had reached $285 million and expectations for a stronger 2016 enrollment period were strong. The exchange did, indeed, turn a corner during 2016 and had its most successful enrollment period since ACA implementation.
Since then, enrollment has been smooth and has increased each year.
Through ACA expansion, Massachusetts Medicaid covers most nonelderly adults up to 138 percent of FPL. Based on eligibility criteria that pre-date the ACA, children in families with incomes up to 305 percent of FPL qualify for Medicaid or the Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP). From 2013 to December 2017, Massachusetts saw its average monthly Medicaid enrollment increase about 29 percent.
Medicaid and CHIP are called MassHealth in Massachusetts. Learn how to apply for MassHealth.
Other ACA reform provisions
The ACA’s Consumer Operated and Oriented Plan (CO-OP) Program was designed to encourage new, non-profit health insurers to enter the market, but most of the CO-OPs failed in the first few years, due in large part to the shortfalls in the ACA’s risk corridors program, and the way the risk adjustment program is structured.
Twenty-four CO-OPs received loans totaling $2.09 billion as of January 2014. In Massachusetts, Minuteman Health, Inc. received more than $156 million in federal loans. See the states where CO-OPs were.
Minuteman Health expanded to New Hampshire for the 2015 coverage year. It remained in operation throughout 2017, but ultimately closed at the end of 2017 and was placed in receivership. As of 2018, there are only four CO-OPs still in operation, after the closure of Minuteman Health.
Massachusetts Medicare enrollment
Massachusetts Medicare enrollment reached 1,218,036 in 2015, about 18 percent of the state population. Historically, about 83 percent of the state’s Medicare beneficiaries qualify based on age alone, while 17 percent are eligible due to disability.
Medicare spends about $8,861 annually per enrollee in Massachusetts, which is above the national average of $8,790. In terms of overall Medicare spending, as of 2009, the state ranks 12th with $11.7 billion per year.
In Massachusetts, Medicare recipients can select a Medicare Advantage plan instead of Original Medicare if they wish to receive additional benefits, and about 21 percent of them do. Nationally, 33 percent of Medicare recipients select Medicare Advantage instead of traditional Medicare.
Medicare recipients can also buy Medicare Part D plans. In 2017, about 53 percent of Massachusetts Medicare beneficiaries chose stand-alone prescription drug coverage, compared with to the national Rx plan enrollment of 44 percent.
Massachusetts health insurance resources
State-based health reform legislation
Scroll to the bottom of this page to see recent state-based legislation related to health reform.
Louise Norris is an individual health insurance broker who has been writing about health insurance and health reform since 2006. She has written dozens of opinions and educational pieces about the Affordable Care Act for healthinsurance.org. Her state health exchange updates are regularly cited by media who cover health reform and by other health insurance experts.