- SHOP enrollment lagged from the start
- Insurers with significant market share that offer both individual and small group coverage are no longer required to offer SHOP plans in order to offer individual plans in the exchange
- Some state-run exchanges have fairly robust SHOP markets, but in states that use HealthCare.gov, SHOP plans are only available in partial areas of 9 states.
- Small business health care tax credit: How it works, and how some businesses can still claim it, even if no SHOP plans are available in their area.
- “Small business” means up to 50 employees in most states
- Year-round enrollment for small businesses
Q. Can small businesses use the ACA’s health insurance marketplaces (exchanges)?
A. The Affordable Care Act created an enrollment platform called SHOP (Small Business Health Options Program), an exchange where businesses could compare plans and enroll in coverage for their employees. Originally, the SHOP exchange was an option in every state, but in the 38 states that use HealthCare.gov, the availability of small-business plans in the exchange changed in 2018. And even among the states that run their own exchanges, some are no longer offering SHOP coverage due to lack of insurer participation.
Instead of having small businesses use the exchange to enroll in coverage, HealthCare.gov now directs them to seek out a broker or contact an insurance company directly. And although the site still maintains a tool where employers can check to see if there are SHOP plans available in their area (for purchase directly from an insurer or with the help of a broker), the tool no longer shows any available plans in most areas. But as described below, there are still SHOP-certified plans available in parts of nine states that use HealthCare.gov.
SHOP enrollment lagged from the start
The Small Business Health Options Program (SHOP) never really took off. As of 2017, HHS reported that there were fewer than 39,000 people enrolled in SHOP coverage across the 26 states with fully federally-run SHOP platforms. Hawaii was the first state to obtain approval for a 1332 waiver, and its purpose was to eliminate the state’s SHOP exchange as of 2017.
Arkansas, Mississippi, and Utah used to run their own SHOP platforms (although all three states used HealthCare.gov for individual market enrollments), but had switched to the federal SHOP platform or a direct-to-carrier process by 2019. Arkansas noted that they would no longer have a SHOP option because insurers were no longer participating in SHOP in Arkansas.
And the lack of insurer participation in SHOP has not been limited to states that use the federally-run exchange. The same thing happened in Washington state as of 2018. And Minnesota, which has a functional state-run exchange for individuals, has discontinued its SHOP platform.
Individual market QHP issuers were allowed to stop offering SHOP plans in 2018
The decline in SHOP participation was due in part to lackluster enrollment in the early years, and also to a rule change that HHS finalized in late 2016. Under the new rule (which took effect for plan years starting in January 2018), insurers that offer individual market coverage through HealthCare.gov are no longer required to offer SHOP coverage, even if they (or an affiliate) have more than 20 percent of the small-group market share in the state.
Prior to 2018, those insurers were required to offer at least one silver and one gold SHOP plan in order to be allowed to offer individual market coverage in the exchange. But HHS eliminated that requirement for plan years starting in 2018 or later.
Some state-run exchanges have fairly robust SHOPs
Although SHOP participation and enrollment was underwhelming in most states, enrollment in SHOP coverage in some of the state-run exchanges has been fairly brisk (although in most cases, far lower than enrollment in individual market plans).
Covered California’s SHOP exchange had 50,000 members as of late 2018, and the exchange was projecting a membership of 60,000 people by the end of the 2019-2020 fiscal year. And DC’s SHOP exchange had more than 80,000 members as of 2020, although that’s driven in large part by the fact that all small-group plans in DC must be purchased through the exchange, and by the fact that members of Congress and their staff obtain coverage through the DC SHOP exchange (Congress members and their staffers and dependents account for about 11,000 of the exchange’s SHOP enrollees).
HealthCare.gov no longer maintains an enrollment portal for SHOP plans, but most of the state-run health insurance exchanges still have SHOP platforms for small businesses. Some use a direct-to-carrier enrollment approach, while others still offer a full-service enrollment platform:
- Colorado (the state-run exchange no longer administers SHOP, but Kaiser still offers SHOP-certified plans in Colorado)
- District of Columbia
- Idaho (enrollments are completed directly with the insurers or via a broker)
- Maryland (enrollments are completed directly with the insurers or via a broker)
- New Mexico (uses HealthCare.gov for individual enrollments, but has its own SHOP platform; as of October 2019, the SHOP platform does not have contribution requirements for employers; businesses can enroll even if the employer is not paying any portion of the premium and is instead having employees payroll deduct the cost)
- New York (eligibility is determined via the exchange site, but as of April 2018, enrollment is done directly with the insurance companies; since the state implemented this change, insurer participation has grown from four to nine, and nine insurers filed plans to continue to offer SHOP plans for 2020).
- Rhode Island
- Vermont (Vermont has always used a direct-to-carrier approach, but all small-group plans in Vermont are SHOP plans, as the state does not allow any non-exchange-certified plans to be sold in the individual or small-group markets).
Small-business health care tax credit
If your business qualified for the small-business health care tax credit, you may be able to pay less in taxes by offering health benefits to your employees — although the tax credit is only available for up to two years, so small businesses cannot count on it for long-term support.
Employers can claim the tax credit on Form 8941 (instructions here). Initially, the small business health care tax credit was only available to employers that purchased their coverage via the SHOP exchange. But as SHOP options dwindled, the IRS issued transitional relief that allowed small businesses to obtain the tax credit even if their plan was purchased outside the SHOP exchange.
However, that provision (most recently in IRS Notice 2018-27) only applies to businesses that initially purchased a plan through the SHOP exchange, and then transitioned to a non-SHOP plan (in 2017 or later) within the two-year window during which they’re eligible to claim the tax credit, because SHOP plans ceased to be available during that two-year window. This is highlighted in Example 3 in IRS Notice 2018-27: The IRS clarifies that the tax credit would not have been available in 2017 for a small business that began operations in 2017 but was in an area where no SHOP plans were available.
The instructions for Form 8941 (see page 5) confirm that this provision applies to all years after 2016. So if an eligible employer began its two-year tax credit window in 2017 or 2018 under a SHOP plan, and was unable to purchase a SHOP plan the following year due to lack of availability, they would be able to enroll in a non-SHOP plan in the second year and still obtain the tax credit.
The IRS notes that employers in most states (those that use HealthCare.gov) can use HealthCare.gov’s search tool to see if there are SHOP plans available. That tool does still work, although most areas that use the federally-run health insurance exchange do not have SHOP-certified plans available as of 2020 (if SHOP plans are available in your area, the tool on HealthCare.gov will show them to you; otherwise, the tool will simply say that there are no SHOP plans available).
How many HealthCare.gov states have SHOP-certified plans available in 2020?
There are SHOP-certified plans available for purchase—directly from an insurer or with the help of a broker—in nine states that use HealthCare.gov in 2020.
According to Public Use Files published by CMS (see the Business Rules PUF), there are quite a few dental-only SHOP plans, but if we limit it to medical SHOP plans, they’re only available in the following states as of 2020 (and coverage areas are often limited to only certain parts of the state):
- Alabama (from Blue Cross Blue Shield of Alabama)
- Georgia (from Kaiser)
- Maine (from Community Health Options)
- Montana (from PacificSource and Montana Health Cooperative)
- New Hampshire (from Anthem/Matthew Thornton)
- New Jersey (from Horizon Health Care Services)
- Ohio (from AultCare)
- Virginia (from CareFirst, GHMSI, and Kaiser)
- Wisconsin (from Security Health Plan of Wisconsin, and Common Ground; there were SHOP plans available from Group Health Cooperative as of 2019, but they’re no longer available in 2020)
[In 2019, there were SHOP plans available in Alaska, Illinois, and Michigan, but none of those states have SHOP plans available as of 2020.]
In addition to the nine states where there are SHOP-certified plans available in 2020, there are still SHOP-certified plans in most of the states that run their own exchanges (detailed above). This includes California, Colorado, Connecticut, DC, Idaho, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Mexico (uses HealthCare.gov for individual plans but has its own exchange for small group plans), New York, Rhode Island, and Vermont.
So if a business is in an area that still has SHOP plans available, the small business health care tax credit is still available to newly-enrolling businesses. And the tax credit is also still available to a business that began its two-year tax credit window under a SHOP plan but then had to transition to a non-SHOP plan because SHOP plans were no longer available. But businesses trying to claim the tax credit for the first time might be out of luck if they’re in an area where there aren’t any SHOP plans available.
‘Small-business’ = up to 50 employees in most states
The SHOP marketplaces were originally open to businesses with up to 50 employees, but that was scheduled to change in 2016, with availability being extended to groups with up to 100 employees. However, the PACE Act, which was signed into law in October 2015, kept the definition of “small group” at 50 or fewer employees.
But there are four states that changed their laws to match the original intent of the ACA. So SHOP marketplaces in Vermont, New York, Colorado, and California are open to businesses with up to 100 employees. All four of those states run their own exchange platforms; they do not use HealthCare.gov (but in most of them, the enrollment process is completed directly through insurers, rather than using the exchange platform).
Year-round enrollment for small businesses
Although small businesses in most states now enroll directly through insurers (which is what most small businesses did all along), nothing has changed about eligibility for coverage. Enrollment in small-business health plans can be done throughout the year (unlike individual health insurance, which is only available during open enrollment or following a qualifying event).
And for groups that aren’t able to meet the participation requirements and/or employer premium contribution requirements, there’s an open enrollment period each fall (November 15 to December 15) when coverage is guaranteed issue regardless of employee participation and/or employer contributions.
Although a small employer can purchase a group plan at any point, employees can only enroll or make changes to their coverage during an annual open enrollment period. This is the same process that has long applied to employer-sponsored coverage.
Louise Norris is an individual health insurance broker who has been writing about health insurance and health reform since 2006. She has written dozens of opinions and educational pieces about the Affordable Care Act for healthinsurance.org. Her state health exchange updates are regularly cited by media who cover health reform and by other health insurance experts.