Get a quote

Get a quote online for health insurance

Call 1-877-809-0501

to get free assistance from a licensed agent

ZIP, click, and pick. Your plan options in seconds.


Or click to call 1-877-809-0501

South Carolina health insurance marketplace

Consumers Choice CO-OP closing at year end; 9th CO-OP to close

  • By
  • contributor
  • October 22, 2015

Consumers Choice CO-OP closing at year end

On October 22, The South Carolina Department of Insurance announced that Consumers Choice – an ACA-created CO-OP – would wind down its operations by year-end, and would not participate in the 2016 open enrollment period that begins November 1. Consumers Choice is the ninth CO-OP to fail, and the fifth in October alone.

The significant shortfall in risk corridors payments is being blamed for the CO-OP’s demise, as is the case for all five of the CO-OPs that have failed in October. HHS announced on October 1 that carriers would get just 12.6 percent of the 2014 risk corridors payments that they were owed, leaving many smaller carriers well into the red. One of the other four CO-OPs that closed as a result of the risk corridor shortfall – Community Health Alliance in Tennessee – was also run by Consumers Choice CEO Jerry Burgess.

67,000 Consumers Choice members will need to secure new coverage for 2016. The Department of Insurance has put together a series of FAQs for impacted plan members.

2016 rates in the exchange

On October 2, South Carolina regulators released approved rate changes fro 2016. The weighted average rate increase at that point was about 15.9 percent (slightly lower in the exchange, slightly higher when off-exchange plans are included). In the exchange, the highest rate increases were for Coventry (Aetna) and Consumer’s Choice. Now that Consumers Choice will no longer be offering plans for 2016, the overall weighted average rate increase will be lower, since Consumers Choice plans were going to see an average rate increase of 22 percent:

  • Coventry (Aetna) proposed rate increases averaging 31.8 percent across all of their ACA-compliant (on and off exchange) plans.  Regulators approved the Coventry/Aetna rates as proposed, and the average rate increase for their plans will be 31.8 percent in 2016. Including both on and off-exchange plans, Coventry’s enrollment stood at 34,000 members as of spring 2015.
  • Consumers Choice (no longer offering plans for 2016) had proposed an average rate increase of 18.4 percent, but regulators increased the rate increase to 22 percent. Including on and off-exchange plans, Consumers Choice enrollment stood at 70,398 members as of April 2015. As of October 22 – when regulators announced that Consumers Choice would not offer plans for 2016 – membership stood at about 67,000 people.

Two additional carriers in the South Carolina exchange – BlueChoice Health Plan and BlueCross BlueShield of South Carolina – both had rate decreases for 2015. And their rate increases for 2016 are single digit:

  • BlueChoice Health Plan: 8.89 percent rate increase approved.
  • BlueCross BlueShield of South Carolina: 8.66 percent rate increase approved.

Time Insurance, which offered on-exchange plans in South Carolina in 2015, initially requested the steepest rate hike (53 percent), but their parent company, Assurant, subsequently announced that they would exit the individual market nationwide; Time products will not be available for sale during the 2016 open enrollment period.

But UnitedHealthcare will be joining the South Carolina exchange for 2016; their products had previously only been available outside the exchange.  UnitedHealthcare began offering off-exchange individual plans in South Carolina in 2015, and they had 4,109 enrollees (all off-exchange) as of when they filed 2016 rates in the spring of 2015.  They have proposed an average rate increase of 19.6 percent on those plans for 2016, although regulators reduced the approved rate increase down to 17.1 percent.

As of 2013, BCBS covered 59 percent of the individual market in South Carolina.  And unlike Blues plans in many other states that have raised rates substantially for 2016, the Blues plans in South Carolina will both have average rate increases of less than nine percent.

Very small rate increases for small groups

In the small group market, the average rate increase for plans sold through the SHOP exchange in South Carolina will be just 1.02 percent for 2016. Market-wide, including off-exchange small group plans, the average rate increase is still less than two percent.

Carriers offering plans in the exchange – 2016

Four carriers will offer individual plans in the South Carolina exchange for 2016:

  • BlueShield Health Plab
  • BlueCross BlueShielf of South Carolina
  • Coventry (Aetna)
  • UnitedHealthcare

In the small group market, two carriers will offer plans through the SHOP exchange:

  • BlueShield Health Plan
  • BlueCross BlueShield of South Carolina

Off-exchange carriers

In addition to the five carriers that offer plans in the exchange, some carriers in South Carolina only offer plans outside the exchange:

  • Celtic
  • Cigna
  • Freedom Life
  • National Foundation Life
  • Coventry and Federated Mutual will offer small group plans only outside the exchange.

2015 enrollment

By the end of the 2015 open enrollment period, a total of 210,331 people in South Carolina had finalized their private plan selections in the exchange.  88,749 of them already had exchange coverage in 2014, and the rest (58 percent of the total) were new to the exchange for 2015.  Total enrollment for 2015 was 177 percent of the enrollment total at the end of the 2014 open enrollment period last spring.

HHS had predicted 150,000 private plan enrollees in South Carolina’s exchange during the 2015 open enrollment period, and the exchange ended up at 140 percent of that target.

But effectuated enrollment is always lower than initial enrollment numbers, because some enrollees don’t pay their premiums and others opt to cancel their coverage mid-year.  As of June 2015, in-force enrollment in private plans through the South Carolina exchange stood at 165,276 people.  88.7 percent are receiving premium subsidies, and 62.7 percent are receiving cost-sharing reductions on silver plans.

Between November 15 and February 22, another 21,106 exchange enrollees were found to be eligible for Medicaid under the state’s existing guidelines, despite the fact that South Carolina has not yet expanded Medicaid.

The only way to purchase a plan for 2015 (on or off exchange) outside of open enrollment is if you have a qualifying event.  For those who remain uninsured this year, the penalty in 2015 will be significantly higher than it was in 2014:  $325 per uninsured adult (half that amount for uninsured children under age 18) or 2 percent of household income, whichever is more.

Open enrollment starts again on November 1, for coverage effective January 2016.

King v. Burwell – subsidies keep flowing

On June 25, the Supreme Court ruled that subsidies are legal in every state, regardless of whether the exchange is run by the state or by HHS.  Subsidies are now safe for 160,000 people in South Carolina, and their coverage will remain affordable.  The Kaiser Family Foundation had estimated that their premiums would have increased an average of 335 percent if subsidies are eliminated.

If subsidies had been eliminated in South Carolina, it would have had a destabilizing effect on the state’s entire individual market.  The Urban Institute had projected rate hikes of 55 percent for people who don’t currently get subsidies, and that’s in addition to the regular annual rate increases based on medical cost inflation.  Moreover, the loss of subsidies and the ensuing “death spiral” for premiums would have resulted in a 70 percent reduction in the number of people covered in the individual market in states like South Carolina.

But none of that will come to pass, because the Supreme Court upheld the subsidies.  That’s good news for the people of South Carolina who purchase their own health insurance, and it’s also good news for the insurance carriers and the medical providers in the state.

Not prepared for the alternate outcome

Governor Nikki Haley had confirmed in early June that the state had no plans to create a state-run exchange, regardless of the outcome of the King case.  Lynn Bailey, a healthcare economist from Columbia, SC, noted that in regards to a possible ruling for the King plaintiffs, “we in no way, shape, or form are prepared in South Carolina.”

But an important part of the government’s defense in the King case was that nobody who was involved with the creation of the law or the exchange establishment process was aware of the supposed incentive to create a state-run exchange.  This is certainly true in South Carolina of the committee that examined the pros and cons of creating an exchange versus defaulting to an HHS-run exchange.  The members of the committee, along with former Senator Mike Rose, reviewed the ACA and ultimately decided that they had “nothing to lose and everything to gain” by having HHS run their exchange.  Clearly, that would not have been the case had they been aware of any possibility that a federally-run exchange could prevent enrollees from receiving subsidies.

2015 South Carolina Rates and carriers

Assurant joined the South Carolina exchange for 2015, bringing the total number of carriers in the exchange to five.  Assurant joined the four companies that were already offering health insurance through the federally-run marketplace in South Carolina:Blue Choice Health Plan, Blue Cross Blue Shield of South Carolina, Consumers’ Choice Health Plan and Coventry Health Care of the Carolinas. (this page has more information about the participating carriers).  There are a total of 52 plans available in the state, although not all of them are available in all areas.

A preliminary report released by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) found premiums in South Carolina to be higher than the national average in 2014. In South Carolina, the average cost for the least-expensive bronze plan in 2014 was $267 a month before tax credits or subsidies. The national average for the lowest cost bronze plans was $249 a month.

But things are a lot better in 2015.  Across the entire individual market – including on and off-exchange – PricewaterhouseCooper LLC has calculated a weighted average rate increase of just 4.3 percent for 2015.  The Commonwealth Fund found that average premiums in the South Carolina exchange increased by 10 percent for 2015, but for silver plans, it was much more muted at just 3 percent.  And the South Carolina Department of Insurance found that the weighted average rate increase in the exchange was just 0.93 percent for 2015, and 0.95 percent for the entire individual market.

In South Carolina, people who had the benchmark plan (second lowest-cost silver plan) in 2014 and who switched to the new benchmark plan for 2015 could see rate decreases for 2015, particularly in the western portion of the state.  In the Greenville area, the benchmark plan as well as the lowest-cost bronze and silver plans are all being offered by a different carrier in 2015 compared with 2014.  And this is the case in much of the rest of the state as well.

2014 enrollment numbers

By April 19, 118,324 South Carolina residents had completed their private plan Obamacare enrollments in the exchange.  In addition, 28,359 exchange applicants had enrolled in Medicaid, qualifying under the state’s existing guidelines (South Carolina has not expanded Medicaid under the ACA).

HHS released a report in June detailing average after-subsidy premiums in the federally facilitate marketplaces, and South Carolina is very much in line with the national averages:  87% of enrollees in the SC exchange received a subsidy, the same as the overall percentage across the 36 HHS-run exchanges.  And the average after-subsidy premium in SC is $84, just two dollars higher than the average across all 36 states

No Medicaid expansion

US Rep. James Clyburn (D – SC) views the ACA as the “Civil Rights Act of the 21st century” and is calling on South Carolina to embrace the law (including Medicaid expansion, which SC lawmakers have thus far resisted) and all that it can offer to the state and its residents.

In his article, Rep. Clyburn notes that SC ranks 43rd in the US in terms of overall health, and points out the myriad ways that the ACA can help to improve residents’ health.

In large part because of the state’s failure to expand Medicaid, the uninsured rate in South Carolina is still higher than the national average.  According to a Gallup poll released in August, 18.7 percent of state’s population was uninsured in 2013.  That rate stood at 16.8 percent as of mid-2014.

Compounding the problem created by the lack of Medicaid expansion in South Carolina, the state’s community health clinics are facing a significant cut in funding by 2016 if the federal government does not re-authorize a five-year trust that was created by the ACA and has been providing funds for community health clinics around the country.  It would need to be reauthorized by October 2015, but officials are not sure that is going to happen.  In SC, where 194,000 people are in the “coverage gap” because the state has not expanded Medicaid, the community health clinics fill a vital role in providing treatment on a sliding fee scale.  But their ability to continue to do is uncertain.

But there is one small sliver of good news in the South Carolina Medicaid program:  starting on December 1, adults who are covered by Medicaid in South Carolina now have coverage for preventive dental coverage, fillings, and extractions with up to $750 in services available for each member per year.

Leadership’s ongoing opposition to ACA

Given Gov. Haley’s outspoken opposition to the Affordable Care Act, it is no surprise that the federal government is running the health insurance marketplace in South Carolina. Haley announced her decision in November 2012.

Despite the fact that nearly 20% of the population in South Carolina is uninsured, the state made headlines in 2014 thanks to anti-ACA legislation.  They started with a bill that would have effectively prohibited the implementation of the the ACA in the state.  

The curiously-named South Carolina Freedom of Health Care Protection Act (H3101) would have blocked state employees from participating in the exchange and would have reimbursed residents facing an IRS penalty for not complying with the ACA’s individual mandate.  The bill passed the SC House last spring, and Governor Nikki Haley supports the legislation.  However, it failed a second reading in the Senate on March 19.  

Republican lawmakers in SC aren’t giving up on their efforts to nullify the ACA though – Senate Republican Tom Davis introduced an amendment to the bill in early March in an effort to continue to fight against the law in a state that desperately needs the ACA.  But in early May, the SC Senate voted 23 – 19 to table the amendment.  Davis believes that Senate Republicans (with a majority) “didn’t deliver“, but uninsured and underinsured South Carolina residents probably see things a little differently.

And then in December 2014, South Carolina Representative Bill Chumley introduced H3020, which would essentially remove the state’s ability to operate an exchange, expand Medicaid, or even assist in enrolling people in the exchange.  It would also prohibit the state from participation in any sort of enforcement of the individual or employer mandates.  The bill was referred to the Committee on Labor, Commerce, and Industry as soon as the legislative session began on January 13, and was still in committee as of early February.

Grandmothered plans

South Carolina was quick to accept President Obama’s policy cancellation compromise that allows carriers to extend existing plans that had been scheduled to terminate at the end of 2013.  And when HHS extended that proposal in early 2014, South Carolina was once again among the majority of states that opted to allow grandmothered plans to renew into 2015.

It was left up to each carrier to determine whether they wan to allow their pre-2014 plans to continue to be eligible for renewal.  This gives many people – who had individual coverage prior to 2014 – another alternative to compare with the options available in the exchange, but some critics contend that it keeps healthy people out of the new ACA-compliant insurance pools.


Three federally funded groups launched training programs and outreach campaigns in 2013 to help consumers understand their options. DECO Recovery Management, Cooperative Ministry, and the Beaufort County Black Chamber of Commerce all received grants to hire “navigators.” Navigators provide unbiased information about the options available through the marketplace and help consumers through the enrollment process, but cannot be directly or indirectly paid by insurance companies.

South Carolina was among the states that received the least amount of federal funding in the initial planning grants – the state got $1 million.  This is a thousand times less than the $1 billion that California received (and several other states got hundreds of millions), but is predicated on the state’s refusal to promote the ACA – the money wouldn’t have been utilized by the South Carolina government.

For the 2016 open enrollment period, two navigator organizations in South Carolina received federal grant funding: the Beaufort County Black Chamber of Commerce ($456,102) and the Palmetto Project ($1,123,916).

Employee choice delayed in SHOP exchange

South Carolina is among the 18 states where the “employee choice” feature of the SHOP exchange has been delayed another year – from 2015 until 2016.  This benefit will eventually allow employees to select from among a broad range of plans selected by the employer, but until 2016, there will be only one plan available for employees to select.

South Carolina health insurance exchange links

State Exchange Profile: South Carolina
The Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation overview of South Carolina’s progress toward creating a state health insurance exchange.

South Carolina Consumer Assistance Program
Assists people insured by private health plans, Medicaid, or other plans in resolving problems pertaining to their health coverage; assists uninsured residents with access to care.
(800) 768-3467  /