No Medicaid expansion in South Dakota
South Dakota has not yet accepted federal funding to expand its Medicaid program, so eligibility rules in the state remain the same as they were prior to the Affordable Care Act (ACA). Former Governor Dennis Daugaard supported Medicaid expansion by 2015 (after initially opposing it), but the issue did not have lawmakers’ support. Current Governor Kristi Noem is opposed to Medicaid expansion.
Accordingly, coverage under Medicaid is only available in South Dakota for those with low income who are either children, elderly, pregnant, disabled, or very low-income parents/caretakers of minor children (parents are only eligible with household income up to 58 percent of the poverty level, which works out to just over $12,000 a year for a household with three people). Children comprise more than two-thirds of the state’s Medicaid population.
Instead of expanding Medicaid, South Dakota is seeking federal approval for a work requirement for low-income parents in the existing Medicaid program. The waiver application is for a pilot program that would be rolled out in Minnehaha and Pennington Counties, with the option to expand into other areas of the state in the future. The waiver is pending CMS approval as of October 2020.
The only people who would be subject to the work requirement are the parents who aren’t already working (or caring for a child under the age of 1), which amounts to a tiny fraction of the state’s total Medicaid population. And, limiting the waiver proposal to a pilot program in Minnehaha and Pennington counties further reduces the total number of people who would initially be subject to the work requirement.
Obviously, young children need childcare well beyond the age of 1. Daugaard’s State of the State address noted that “for those families whose income goes up, we will provide interim resources such as child care assistance and premium assistance to support families as they transition off Medicaid.” The waiver proposal notes that households subject to the Career Connector requirements would also be eligible for childcare assistance, and that “participants receiving childcare subsidy will be provided with [childcare] copayment assistance so as income increases, and child care out of pocket costs increase, the transition is gradual instead of immediate.”
South Dakota began voluntary enrollment in the Career Connector program in July 2018. Mandatory enrollment in Minnehaha and Pennington counties will begin if and when HHS approves the state’s waiver proposal.
South Dakota Medicaid expansion may be in voters’ hands in 2022
of Federal Poverty Level
South Dakota may be the next to have the opportunity to determine whether Medicaid is expanded in the state under the terms laid out in the ACA. In July 2020, South Dakota Attorney General Jason Ravnsborg published explanations for two petitions that will be circulated in the state in an effort to gain enough signatures to get on the 2022 ballot. Both call for Medicaid expansion in South Dakota under the terms of the ACA — one would create a constitutional amendment (like the ballot approach that Oklahoma used) and the other is an initiated measure that would direct the state legislature to expand Medicaid.
The proposals are sponsored by Rick Weiland, a former U.S. Senate candidate and former regional director of FEMA. Medicaid expansion advocates in South Dakota have until November 2021 to gather enough signatures to get the measures on the 2022 ballots. They need almost 17,000 signatures to get the initiated measure on the ballot, and almost 34,000 to get the constitutional amendment on the ballot. Either measure, if successful, would result in expanded Medicaid in South Dakota. Both ballot initiatives call for the state to submit a state plan amendment to the federal government within 90 days of passage, detailing the state’s plan for the expansion of Medicaid.
For now, South Dakota is one of 12 states that where Medicaid has not been expanded. Low-income childless adults without a disability are ineligible for Medicaid regardless of how low their income is, but they’re not eligible for premium subsidies to offset the cost of private coverage unless their income is at least 100 percent of the poverty level. This leaves an estimated 14,000 low-income South Dakota adults in the coverage gap, with no access to any financial assistance with their health coverage. If Medicaid is expanded as called for in the ACA, a single person would qualify for Medicaid in South Dakota with an income of up to about $17,600 (that number increases a little each year as the poverty level rises).
Polling indicates that voters in South Dakota are in favor of Medicaid expansion. A non-scientific poll being conducted by a Sioux Falls newspaper, the Argus Leader, had 490 votes as of October 2016, and 81 percent of them were in favor of Medicaid expansion. The South Dakota State Medical Association is also pushing for Medicaid expansion in the state.
Does South Dakota have a Medicaid work requirement?
Instead of an effort to expand Medicaid, South Dakota state officials want to implement a work requirement for low-income parents in the existing Medicaid population. Former Governor Dennis Daugaard laid out the details in his State of the State address in January 2018, and the state published the proposed waiver application in May 2018 (and did not provide some crucial details to enable to public to accurately comment on the proposal). After the state’s public comment period, the waiver application was sent to HHS, where it was deemed complete and is still under review nearly two years later.
South Dakota’s waiver proposal would roll out a Medicaid work requirement (the Career Connector program) for low-income parents/caretakers (non-parents/caretakers are not eligible for Medicaid in South Dakota regardless of how low their income is, because the state hasn’t expanded Medicaid) as a pilot program in the two most populous counties in the state: Minnehaha and Pennington. The state chose those counties because of their population and access to job training and employment opportunities.
Then-Governor Daugaard’s 2018 State of the State address did not mention Medicaid expansion, other than to point out that since the state has not expanded Medicaid, the existing Medicaid population is mostly exempt from a work requirement. There would be exemptions for children, the elderly, parents caring for children under the age of 1, pregnant women, and disabled individuals.
To be in compliance with the work requirement, non-exempt parents would have to work at least 80 hours per month. The state projects that 1,300 people would be in the Career Connector program annually, and that about 15 percent of those participants would lose their eligibility for Medicaid each year. The state estimates that “the majority” of the people who lose Medicaid eligibility would do so because of an increase in income, but that a “small number” would lose their Medicaid coverage due to “choosing not to participate in the program.” People who lose coverage due to an increase in income would be eligible for a year of transitional Medicaid coverage and an additional year of premium assistance.
Who is eligible for Medicaid in South Dakota?
- Pregnant women with household incomes up to 133 percent of the federal poverty level (FPL)
- Children aged 0 to 18 with household income up to 182 percent of FPL are eligible for Medicaid; Children with household incomes up to 204 percent of poverty are eligible for CHIP (Children’s Health Insurance Program).
- Parents with dependent children are eligible with incomes up to 58 percent of poverty.
See the South Dakota Department of Social Services website for eligibility guidelines on additional Medicaid services (e.g., for the aged, blind and disabled) and other supportive programs and services.
How do I apply for Medicaid in South Dakota?
Medicaid enrollment is open year-round. You can apply for South Dakota Medicaid online, over the phone, or by submitting a paper application. If you have questions, you can reach the SD Department of Social Services at 1-605-773-3165.
- Online: Visit HealthCare.gov
- By phone: Call HealthCare.gov at 1-800-318-2596.
- Paper applications: Download an application for Medicaid or CHIP from the South Dakota Department of Social Services website. The application must then be mailed, faxed, or taken in person to a local Social Services office.
South Dakota Medicaid enrollment numbers
Enrollment in South Dakota’s Medicaid program is just slightly lower in June 2020 than it was in January 2014. Because the state has not expanded Medicaid, enrollment has not grown the way it did in most other states. There were 114,059 people enrolled as of June 2020, compared to 114,779 in January 2014.
South Dakota Medicaid history
South Dakota’s Medicaid program became effective in October 1967, nearly two years after Medicaid was created. For many states, 2014 represented a significant shift in eligibility, particularly for childless adults. However, South Dakota Medicaid eligibility guidelines have not yet changed under the ACA. Non-disabled childless adults are ineligible for Medicaid, regardless of how low their incomes are.
South Dakota Medicaid expansion history
South Dakota officials announced in September 2015 that their proposal to expand Medicaid had received “an initial go ahead” from HHS. Governor Daugaard’s senior advisor Kim Malsam-Rysdon noted that the plan was still preliminary, but it appeared promising and would expand eligibility to far more people than the state’s 2014 proposal, which would only have expanded coverage to residents with incomes below the poverty level (HHS rejected that proposal, as Medicaid expansion capped at the poverty level was a non-starter under the Obama administration, and was also rejected by the Trump administration when proposed by Utah).
Of the population that would have been newly eligible for coverage under Medicaid expansion, more than a quarter — about 14,000 people — are Native Americans, although Native Americans make up just nine percent of the South Dakota population. Native Americans are disproportionately impacted by the state’s refusal to expand Medicaid. Although they are eligible for free care through Indian Health Services, the treatment options are limited at those facilities. The approval from HHS to allow non-IHS providers to enter into care coordination agreements with IHS facilities was expected help to open up treatment options for Native Americans with Medicaid coverage, with full funding from the federal government, but Daugaard had noted that it’s a complicated process, and not all providers enter into those agreements.
Although states that expanded Medicaid are paying 10 percent of the cost (as of 2020; it will remain at that level in the future), Daugaard noted that his proposal would end up being a financial net-positive for the state. That’s because he was working with the federal government and Native American tribal leaders to use Medicaid funding for Native Americans who are eligible for expanded Medicaid and who receive treatment outside of Indian Health Services (IHS) facilities. Those costs are covered in part by the state, and Daugaard said that South Dakota would save more there than they would spend on their portion of the Medicaid expansion costs. Daugaard said that he wouldn’t continue his push for Medicaid expansion if it ended up needing additional money from the state’s general fund.
In December 2015, Governor Daugaard explained the details of his $4.8 billion budget proposal, including his proposal to expand Medicaid to cover 55,000 people who weren’t currently eligible. Daugaard said that the state should “seize the opportunity” to use federal funding to expand coverage, if possible.
In February 2016, HHS agreed to establish arrangements under which non-IHS providers could enter into “care coordination agreements” with IHS facilities, and Native Americans enrolled in Medicaid would be able to receive care at those non-IHS facilities and the full cost would be covered by federal Medicaid funds (as opposed to the state paying a portion and the federal government paying a portion). But Daugaard noted that the practical implementation of the new HHS provision could be complicated, and that there was still work to be done to determine whether the savings from the new IHS rule would save enough money to make Medicaid expansion budget-neutral in South Dakota.
A few days later, Daugaard said that it was too late in the 2016 legislative session to get the ball rolling on Medicaid expansion, and said that he would remove Medicaid expansion from his proposed budget. He indicated that a special session was a possibility, but that waiting until the 2017 legislative session was also a possibility. In June 2016, Daugaard confirmed that the issue would have to wait until the 2017 legislative session, as he was opting not to call a special session in 2016.
In early 2017, in his State of the State address, Daugaard noted that he was optimistic about working with the Trump administration to ensure that the federal government would begin to fully fund medical care for Native Americans, regardless of where the care was provided, without requiring “health care providers to jump through several hoops,” as he believed the Obama-era arrangement did. He did not mention Medicaid expansion in that address.
The issue of Medicaid expansion was essentially off the table in South Dakota as of early 2017. The coalition tasked with recommending how the state should expand coverage updated their conclusions in December 2016 to note that Governor Daugaard was no longer recommending Medicaid expansion for 2017, in light of the incoming Trump administration’s plans to overhaul Medicaid nationwide with block grants or per-capita allotments. Ultimately, that did not come to pass at the federal level, but no progress has been made towards Medicaid expansion in South Dakota in the meantime. Kristi Noem took office as governor in 2019, and opposes Medicaid expansion.
Louise Norris is an individual health insurance broker who has been writing about health insurance and health reform since 2006. She has written dozens of opinions and educational pieces about the Affordable Care Act for healthinsurance.org. Her state health exchange updates are regularly cited by media who cover health reform and by other health insurance experts.